Submitted by James19991 t3_ycfx2g in pittsburgh

This was actually the only Walmart within the city limits, but it will be no more as of 11/11. In the article, they cite poor performance, which doesn't really surprise me given it is a rather small store compared to many Walmarts and Targets of today. I'm not a fan of Walmart much, but it was serviced by several bus routes and now the closest thing of similar format would be the Target in East Liberty. For those of us over the age of 30, we remember it as the old Hills/Ames location.

https://www.bizjournals.com/pittsburgh/news/2022/10/24/walmart-jj-gumberg-waterworks-shopping-center.html?ana=TRUEANTHEMFB_PI&csrc=6398&utm_campaign=trueAnthem%3A+New+Content+%28Feed%29&utm_medium=trueAnthem&utm_source=facebook

220

Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

citylifeadventures t1_itlvs6o wrote

Ugh. I agree it’s really limited but it was so nice to stop in for non grocery items without having to drive all the way up to Pittsburgh Mills.

127

James19991 OP t1_itlwwod wrote

Yeah, it definitely wasn't that great of a store and I don't really care for Walmart in general, but it absolutely served a purpose for that area. I'm not sure what could be interested in taking that store space too. There is a Target not that far from there already, and the days of smaller regional discount department store chains like Ames has been over for 20 years now.

56

citylifeadventures t1_itlypjf wrote

Probably Spirit Halloween next year 😂 😭

80

[deleted] t1_itm8u0j wrote

[deleted]

53

DirtNapsRevenge t1_itn3xtp wrote

Thunderdome style please...

Six mattress stores enter one mattress store leaves.

5

James19991 OP t1_itm1gsa wrote

Maybe if it's still empty 🤣. I just remembered that there's also a Target in Harmar as well, if it's fine that it's not Walmart for a discount chain!

8

mr_pgh t1_itn1csq wrote

Harmar Target just had a huge renovation.. so it's apparently doing great.

6

Costanzaslife23 t1_itm5c9t wrote

My money’s on Homegoods or Going! Going! Gone! for that space.

18

PunkRockKing t1_itmzdrx wrote

We actually really need this, since Bed, Bath and Beyond closed over the pandemic. I need a good place for towels and bedding

3

RadicalAns t1_itn15rn wrote

That store used to be an Ames back in the day.

10

DjNuppie t1_itnmvhg wrote

When you realize just how old you are (I'm 41)... I remember going there as Hills and Zares (or Zales my ancient brain can't rember exactly) and if they didn't have what mom needed it was off to phar-mor we walk

11

JustHereForTheSaul t1_ito358f wrote

Wasn't it Zayres? I don't remember one being at that location -- I only remember Hills -- but I think that was the name of the chain.

6

Legal-Ad7793 t1_itoq53j wrote

My mom was a Hills stores manager when I was little. Now it's a Roses. I miss Phar-Mor & Kmart too!

2

James19991 OP t1_itn7s9f wrote

I'm old enough to remember when it was. These days, Walmart prefers Supercenters or their Neighborhood format places over spaces of this size in the middle too.

3

stoogemcduck t1_itmkic6 wrote

I wouldn’t be surprised if Aldi moved in. that plaza is unusually far away from the nearest store for as high traffic as it is, they’re pretty aggressive about expansion and probably don’t like how much area Giant Eagle’s getting to itself there.

9

PunkRockKing t1_itmzosl wrote

Giant Eagle fights to keep other grocers out, that’s why the Walmart there never had full groceries. I’d love a Trader Joe’s

15

bdoc01 t1_itn7t83 wrote

yup they have non-competes in their leases. sometimes they don’t get re-upped but it’s definitely a blocker in many areas.

1

phasmos t1_ito6cyu wrote

More than once, I've emailed Trader Joe's and recommended the vacant Community Market in the next plaza over on Freeport. No response. The rumor I heard is that Giant Eagle bought the space for the express purpose of keeping competition out, which wouldn't surprise me much.

For a while, Fresh Market was planning to open a branch there. It's a Whole Foods-type organic food market; the existing local store is by the Galleria in Mt. Lebanon. They eventually backed out.

A Trader Joe's on that side of the river would be fantastic. More likely, they'd plunk another Aldi in there, but it's just been sitting there empty for years now.

5

mhoppy86 t1_itpy60e wrote

Giant Eagle owned the space already, leasing it out to the Community Market, through their Echo Realty division. Giant Eagle was also the distributor for the store, so they made money through wholesaling and rent.

2

bangarangrufiOO t1_itmmtok wrote

They’d have to split the building, bc Aldi only needs about 1/4th that space.

7

James19991 OP t1_itmoj1k wrote

Eh, that building is way too large for an Aldi.

7

DrKeithOctagon t1_itnulse wrote

The Aldi in Peters Township was built in a portion of an old KMart. The rest of the old KMart still exists / is attached to it.

1

DeadlyBrad42 t1_itmfh0n wrote

There is a Target up the street, however critically it is not on a bus line. This Walmart seemed to be a solid location for folks to access without needing their own transport.

Edited! Didn't realize the Target is on the bus line, although it's probably an extra transfer away now for most folks.

6

cosa_horrible t1_itn0uf9 wrote

The 1 goes to the Target in Harmar. It is 100% on the bus line.

11

drewbaccaAWD t1_itm12qc wrote

What's nearby now, I think a Ross? So probably another one of those types... Marshalls, TJ Maxx, etc. At least that would give an option for some basic housewares. Wouldn't be a bad spot for an Ollies.

Not a huge fan of Walmart either but sorry to see it go, it was convenient although I haven't lived/worked in that area for half a decade now.

5

James19991 OP t1_itm18u6 wrote

I think there's already a TJ Maxx and Marshalls at that mall, unless they've closed in the nearly 5 years since I frequented that area. Ollie's would be a good thing to have there I think.

16

thatdude778 t1_itmnlxz wrote

Theres an Ollie's a few miles away where the old Kmart was on Route 8.

I think they should just put a Best Buy In there.

6

awesomecatdad t1_itmjfqj wrote

Both still there, next door to each other, over by the book store.

5

Logical-Rip-8138 t1_itmglaz wrote

Marshall’s is already in that plaza.

5

drewbaccaAWD t1_itmipzt wrote

The problem I'm having is that I'm picturing like 10 different plazas in my mind and trying to remember which is where (without pulling up a map). I should have just pulled up the map. lol thanks. I usually stop by that area when I go to the Aspinwall VA but I haven't been there since pre-pandemic.

1

dpawaters t1_itqssfk wrote

We need a Sierra in the Pittsburgh area. Like a Marshall's version of REI (owned by Tjmaxx, etc)

https://www.sierra.com/

2

drewbaccaAWD t1_itqvge6 wrote

Formerly known as Sierra Trading Post.. I know it well.

I didn't realize they had physical stores? I've ordered from Sierra a few times!

2

switman t1_itlye3t wrote

I don't think I've ever heard about a Walmart closing before. Though I'm sure it's not the first time it's happened in SWPA

59

drewbaccaAWD t1_itm1kfq wrote

My suspicion is that they would have kept it if there was space to convert to a "super Walmart" with larger grocery selection... they've been moving away from stores that have limited space. Usually it's just a move right down the road but probably not an option for this one.

45

dewmahn t1_itmq7td wrote

So it's interesting they've been moving away from stores with limited space in some places but in other places they now have neighborhood markets which are like small grocery stores with a few other odds and ends.

8

drewbaccaAWD t1_itms2qw wrote

>in other places they now have neighborhood markets which are like small grocery stores with a few other odds and ends.

I haven't seen that. Walmart? Good business move if they're doing that now. Sounds like the Dollar General model.

7

DjNuppie t1_itnnrs5 wrote

I recently just moved to butler county. I have according to Google maps, 9 DG stores within 6.7 miles of my house 2 of them are 1.8 miles exactly from house !!

6

drewbaccaAWD t1_ito98y4 wrote

I never thought the number of bars and churches in rural PA could be topped... but DG was like "hold my beer!"

2

Willow-girl t1_itprn42 wrote

They are building one in Midway, FFS! I am stoked. Between it and Amazon, I will never have to go to town again ...

3

dewmahn t1_itmuwew wrote

Ya visited some friends recently in Myrtle Beach and they have quite a few.

5

Elouiseotter t1_itojjxk wrote

I drove from Pittsburgh up to Maine on all non highway roads last autumn. There were so many Dollar Generals.

3

typingfrombed t1_itonr2h wrote

In nice suburbs the Neighborhood Walmart format is quite excellent. Everything you’d have at a normal grocery, wide selection of home supplies like cleaning supplies, pharmacy and beauty.. all at the expected low Walmart prices.

I always wondered why this watermarks WM didn’t get turned into a neighborhood WM but I guess the GE lease exclusivity situation someone mentioned above is probably why

2

LetterheadNo4396 t1_itnj3ai wrote

Those stores are for higher economic areas, they'd never build there.

0

sawamander t1_itombmd wrote

Nah, neighborhood markets appear in hyper-low-income areas all the time in the Southeast.

1

montani t1_itm16b6 wrote

Usually they close because they are opening a much bigger one across the street

21

switman t1_itm2w7u wrote

Exactly, I guess I meant that I've never heard of Walmart pulling out of an area like this

5

Elouiseotter t1_itmemny wrote

They might be in talks to develop a store nearby but the info isn’t public yet.

7

DjNuppie t1_itnobc9 wrote

With the mills a few exits up 28 they may just be cutting thier losses unless going somewhere in sharpsburg or etna maybe but don't know where enough available land is besides the old forms and surfaces warehouse that been up for sale

1

funkyb t1_itml1fr wrote

That Walmart got so much ire from the locals when it went in. Everyone I grew up around liked to say that as soon as it went in crime a the mall went straight up. We'll see how things go now that it'll be gone.

The narrative will probably flip back to it being a bussing problem.

36

James19991 OP t1_itmoh8g wrote

I remember not everyone was thrilled in that area about a Walmart being next door when it opened.

12

OcelotWolf t1_itm0hbt wrote

Oof. I don’t shop at Walmart very often but when I did, it was here. Closest one by a decent margin, and even then it was not that close.

24

susinpgh t1_itm36i1 wrote

Yeah, I don't drive and this was an accessible destination where I could pick up generic dry goods. I just took a trip out there, which I do about every six weeks. The E Liberty Target isn't nearly as convenient. Sad, but oh well.

13

SidFarkus47 t1_itm90dh wrote

Yep the fact that this store was on the 91 busline made it very easily accessible to Lawrenceville. All I can hope for is something else useful to go into that space.

9

Tnkgirl357 t1_itpwe6i wrote

Right? I don’t like having to go far out of town. It’s too much of a hassle.

1

The_Wkwied t1_itmtq24 wrote

Ahhh... Remember when Hills closed and turned into Ames?

Ahhh... Remember when Ames closed and turned into WalMart?

Ahhh... Remember when WalMart closes? I wonder what it'll be next.

22

DiscoTheWolf t1_itmwg2y wrote

Aldi

21

koia78 t1_iugm6rb wrote

you think? it’s right over the bridge

1

James19991 OP t1_itmys0n wrote

Fun fact: according to wikipedia, a few days ago on October 19th was the 20th anniversary of Ames shutting down all of its stores.

8

CL-MotoTech t1_ito20dl wrote

Pharmore about to make a come back, let's just hope Little Caesers next door finally makes a pizza worth the $5 they charge.

8

These_Plastic5571 t1_ito97tr wrote

I miss Phar More! But the owner or majority stockholder (I forget which) went to court over unpaid taxes or something shady financially.

3

gullible_guy t1_itm0j4m wrote

The real reason is theft.
A friends wife works there and the theft is insane.

20

CARLEtheCamry t1_itm2blf wrote

A few years ago the one in Robinson started locking up their men's underwear shortly after implementing the self-checkout lane. Bonkers. Like I'm not even going to look at electronics in a Walmart because you can never find an associate to unlock the case for you, I'm most certainly not going to deal with the hassle of doing that for a 5 pack of Hanes.

I'm sure Walmart has a formula of shrinkage vs staffing where it's still in their favor to let people walk off with stuff. Sounds like this store tipped the scale too far.

17

DisFigment t1_itp5uj1 wrote

They also have what I like to call the prison gates at the entrance which don’t let you go back out through the entrance should you not find what you’re looking for.

1

MrCellini t1_itm1dw6 wrote

Yeah, I can only imagine what it’s like now but back in 2014 this Walmart used more anti theft measures than any store I had ever seen. They were removing security tags from everything including plastic bins

5

awesomecatdad t1_itmkm7e wrote

The giant eagle by my house puts anti theft tags on their hoagies. It’s insane.

5

tzeriel t1_itmn7j2 wrote

That whole shopping center is like that I’m guessing. I used to go to Ichiban a lot when I lived down there, and it’s the only place I’ve ever eaten where I’ve watched at least five groups I can remember get caught trying to skip out on their bill.

Still a bummer, but isn’t there a giant Eagle, another grocery store the next plaza down, as well as like 5 clothing stores? Nothing really is being lost that isn’t able to be found in that area. Plus something similar gonna love in.

4

DisFigment t1_itp64gd wrote

I think the plaza will be missing electronics, hardware, automotive, and general household items as categories.

3

balou918 t1_itnl0vl wrote

This is bad news for folks like me that don't drive. There's still a Giant Eagle at Waterworks, but their prices have gotten ridiculously expensive.

19

James19991 OP t1_itnu4uq wrote

At least there's Marshalls, Ross, and TJ Maxx for clothes at a decent price. I agree though that the prices at Market District are obscene for even basic goods compared to Walmart

5

Neither_Squirrel t1_itm50ji wrote

given that the 2 locations closest to the city, Carnegie and Waterworks, have been in the state they’ve been in for… years? I cannot say I’m surprised, especially when all of the Targets seem to be pushing updates

14

[deleted] t1_itmyg66 wrote

[removed]

8

Jupichan t1_itooj1z wrote

Oh lord, can rt 50 handle that kind of traffic? It's already a goddamn clusterfuck trying to get in and out of there.

2

These_Plastic5571 t1_itq0et0 wrote

YES! Look at 50 down the bottom of the hill in Bridgeville. That is only getting worse.

2

Jupichan t1_itqa7qz wrote

I currently work just off that part of 50. Thankfully I can take Bower Hill whenever they don't have it all bollocksed up.

Also thankful to be moving to a different office soon, roughly a minute from where I'll be living very soon.

1

Neither_Squirrel t1_itn946d wrote

Respectfully, please don’t get personally offended … over a Walmart. 😂 I mean old and dingy and out of date, very small grocery sections.

1

These_Plastic5571 t1_ito9oka wrote

That’s my Walmart - Carnegie - it’s busy all the time! The parking lot is a nightmare. Hopefully, they will be able to figure something out with the lot and exiting there.

1

DisFigment t1_itp5oyc wrote

Maybe they could buyout the Ford dealership and McDonald’s to reconfigure the entryway / light?

2

These_Plastic5571 t1_itq08un wrote

You ain’t kidding there. That’s so bad now. Can’t even comprehend what that will be like after it turns into a super Walmart.

1

SilverFirePrime t1_itr5gok wrote

I worked at the Shop N Save for 2.5 years. I don't know how I didnt't get into an accident or see any accidents at the 4-way stop between all the stores.

2

These_Plastic5571 t1_itre529 wrote

Yes! I hold my breath every time I go into the plaza! It’s insane! And people running the stop sign after leaving the Walmart, that is so bad.

1

Willow-girl t1_itprccp wrote

Is that the one that has all merchandise over $10 locked up in glass showcases? And no one to open the showcases. I walked around for awhile searching for an employee -- I had wanted some socks -- but eventually gave up, went home and ordered them from Amazon.

1

totmacherr t1_itnh72k wrote

I foolishly got a cheese and meat plate thing from the grocery area in September, and grabbed one while in a rush, and the one I purchased was in the front, and it's sell by date was in 2020. I knew that place had to have been suffering for a looong time. I hope they replace it with something better maintained!

14

DefinitelyLevi t1_itmwtyz wrote

This Walmart looks vintage af inside

11

James19991 OP t1_itmxobg wrote

I remember a lot of people hated how it was inside from the day it opened.

6

DefinitelyLevi t1_itmxsx7 wrote

The only thing missing is getting free smiley face stickers when you walk in

6

phasmos t1_itpe7kp wrote

The smokers outside + the synthetic retail fume wafting out the front door = the exact smell of Dart Drugs in Rockville, MD circa 1979. 🎯 (It's where I bought JAWS 2 trading cards on the way to school. ⚡️🦈⛵️🚁)

3

Cyanide_Skull t1_ito110k wrote

As someone who works at the mills

Fuck

11

cooldude_4000 t1_itmi0gd wrote

Looking at it on Google Maps, it 's not nearly as large as I thought. Looks like the square footage is about the same as that of the Giant Eagle in the same plaza.

10

PunkRockKing t1_itmzxur wrote

That’s intentional. Giant Eagle kept them small they have some ownership control over the plaza and work hard to keep other supermarkets away. If they’re leaving finally it’s because GE kept them small and unprofitable

14

Tubbie0204 t1_itm1gjc wrote

Does that mean they’ll have a closing sale?

9

James19991 OP t1_itm1yg1 wrote

I wouldn't expect anything big from what I've heard. They'll just send any unsold inventory to other nearby stores.

36

RiversKiski t1_itmy2ql wrote

Sale starts monday

3

Afr0Playz t1_itne08r wrote

So today? Or next week?

1

RiversKiski t1_itnf1r8 wrote

Next week. Walmarts rarely close but when they do, the entire store gets written off as a loss and everything starts at 25% off and will eventually go to 50 the last week or so. Least that’s what happened back in 2016 when I was working there.

11

koia78 t1_iugmcm1 wrote

it’s 25%now but they close everyday at 8 now

1

Tubbie0204 t1_iugmglt wrote

Storewide?

1

koia78 t1_iuib8wy wrote

no which is bullshit. it’s just select things for now. i’m assuming when it’s closer to the close date they’ll put everything on sale. that walmart literally sucks so much i’m not shocked they are closing.

1

undercookedchimken t1_itmouco wrote

theres also a target in harmarville on the bus line

7

James19991 OP t1_itmsz7l wrote

I believe only the 1 goes out to that Target, so those in the city who would have taken the 91 or 75 would have to transfer to get out to that Target.

5

Cryptic_Skies t1_itqdywl wrote

The 75 gets within spitting distance of the east liberty target.

the 64 goes to the target in homestead. the 64 and 91 both go thru lawrenceville.

there are options for city-residents that dont want to go to harmar.

2

JustTryingMyBestWPA t1_itr22cv wrote

You can take the P10 to the port authority Park and Ride (Harmarville) that is next to the Target, and then walk to Target from the Park and Ride. However, the P10 only runs during rush hour, M-F.

1

SK360 t1_itne31p wrote

Can we get Hills back now?

7

James19991 OP t1_itnfhg3 wrote

I loved that place as a kid! It's a shame mid-sized regional discount chains like that don't really exist anymore.

3

SK360 t1_itnmd66 wrote

I liked Hills but to be honest I always just wanted to go to Service Merchandise next door. Something about just writing down what you wanted and having it come down the conveyor after you paid was intriguing to young me

4

James19991 OP t1_itnu1pk wrote

I vaguely remember that place, not as well as Hills though.

3

DisFigment t1_itp55s2 wrote

I’m hoping Meijer comes to Pittsburgh eventually. They’ve come as far east as Youngstown / Cleveland.

3

James19991 OP t1_itptw25 wrote

I've been in a Meijer once, and it was definitely way larger than what the soon to be vacant space in the Waterworks offers. I didn't realize they were now in Youngstown and so close to Pennsylvania. Though I guess if BJ's found two places to put their large warehouse stores this year, so could Meijer.

1

SucksToYourAssmar3 t1_itnpawa wrote

I know one thing - when prices drop to 25-90% off that week, it will be like Mad TJ Maxx. I cannot wait.

6

JustTryingMyBestWPA t1_itr13ub wrote

I am sure that they will pack up the "good stuff" and ship it to another store. That's what happened when my local Kmart was closed. All of the "store closing" inventory was crap.

2

Ham_Ahoy t1_itmpqwe wrote

I heard Fischer's Big Wheel is moving in

4

James19991 OP t1_itmxzit wrote

It's crazy to think of but when I was born in the early 90s, Walmart wasn't even in Pittsburgh and was barely in the Northeast before its presence exploded throughout the 90s and early 2000s. I'm old enough to remember when it was Kmart, Hills, and Ames for the discount chains of choice here.

3

Ham_Ahoy t1_itnhmd4 wrote

Recently I was doing some home renovations and was replacing a light switch. . . The old one still had a Fischer's Big Wheel price tag on it.

2

thecrowfly t1_itnlx03 wrote

It' the absolute worst Wal-mart. Good riddance! Hope something cool moves in.

4

Minimum-Giraffe9737 t1_ito4f8s wrote

I worked there as a temp and that was a shady back door Walmart in many ways

4

esotweetic t1_itobhlj wrote

Downtown Target: and where did that bring you?

Back to me.

4

MisanthropicFriend t1_itof9p1 wrote

:( i always ride 91 up there and relive my (middle of nowhere) childhood and walk around Walmart. I will miss that nostalgia sanctuary.

4

mikeg2323 t1_itptlbt wrote

bring back Hills!

4

Logical-Rip-8138 t1_itnqzz3 wrote

Wonder why they would close at the very start of their busiest time of year? I mean, why not wait till at least Jan 1st?

2

mhoppy86 t1_itns8t4 wrote

So they don't have to hire the help and bring in holiday inventory.

12

James19991 OP t1_itnuczg wrote

Hopefully that mall is slightly less of a zoo this holiday season without Walmart there.

3

DisFigment t1_itp6g4r wrote

That’ll actually hurt the smaller retailers and restaurants since they won’t have one of the two anchors open.

3

PamZero t1_itpjcki wrote

Definitely the worst Walmart around

2

[deleted] t1_itqeobw wrote

[deleted]

1

PamZero t1_itqhk3p wrote

It’s still a better Walmart than waterworks. Personally I think the Pittsburgh mills Walmart is the best around. Plus there is a Sam’s club right next door and Sam’s club gas right there.

1

joeykirkle t1_itprgim wrote

It was always a weird experience shopping in there. Gonna miss it though

2

sackcrusher89 t1_itod2w0 wrote

Hell yeah, boost up the surrounding community.

1

nastyky199 t1_itpxfki wrote

Down south, like Biloxi and panhandle Florida, they have Walmart Neighborhood Markets. Instead of a full blown store, it's like our Get Go Marketplace. Gas and almost an entire food section compared to a normal Walmart, but the other half is minimal housing and vehicle sections. It was our place to shop while visiting family down there. I don't understand why we're lacking places like that up here. Especially within the city limits. Edit, spelling

1

mhoppy86 t1_itsxdun wrote

Space in residential areas that makes it cost-prohibitive, in addition to already intense competition. Dollar Generals and Aldis are much smaller footprints and beat Walmart on some prices. Giant Eagle also can compete if a Neighborhood Market doesn't have departments like a deli, bakery, pharmacy, etc.

1

Chretien7283 t1_iu4c06s wrote

Does anyone know what the sales will be?

1

koia78 t1_iuglu1o wrote

if they turned it into a super walmart they’d be fine 🙄 but they won’t bc it’s too small

1

SystemOfADowneyJr t1_itmrt2d wrote

I’m honestly surprised it lasted this long. That area is pretty snooty (from what I remember anyway) and a lot of people weren’t pleased with the Walmart since it made the plaza “less desirable”.

0

PunkRockKing t1_itn04nz wrote

It was already considered a discount mall with TJ Maxx, Marshalls and Ross. Never really upscale like ones in Cranberry

3

DisFigment t1_itp6cat wrote

Nothing in Cranberry is upscale. It’s like five versions of the same plaza as Waterworks. They have Ross and Marshall’s too.

8

SystemOfADowneyJr t1_itnlnmo wrote

Damn, really? Wow I’m actually surprised. Maybe those folks just didn’t like Walmart 🤷🏾‍♀️🤷🏾‍♀️

1

JustTryingMyBestWPA t1_itr1pvc wrote

I remember that when I first came to Pittsburgh from Somerset. One of my old friends who already lived in the area told me that the Waterworks was one of the "rich" malls. This was about 20 years ago. I have to laugh now, because I personally don't think of this mall was a "rich mall."

3

marshmellow_delight t1_itmx8v2 wrote

I didn’t even know it was there. I would have frequented it had I known…

−1

Alvindm03 t1_itmixq6 wrote

Dollar General bought the property.

−6

LovedAJackass t1_itpswlh wrote

What "city limits"?

−6

James19991 OP t1_itpustr wrote

The City of Pittsburgh? The Waterworks Mall is part of the city.

6

Afr0Playz t1_itndqiy wrote

Down bad for a Chick-fil-A, mini/market Walmart, Nike store a lot closer to downtown ;)

−7