Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

tommy0guns t1_j25gsfc wrote

A 5 should never be given since you can’t rate higher should you find something better. A 1 should rarely be given since people took the time and money to put something together. You should be able to find some value (lighting, dialog, camerawork, end purpose, etc). If you find yourself watching an actual 1…question what got you in this situation and your choices.

1

5thInferno OP t1_j25hj7h wrote

That’s assuming there can only be one 5 though. Why can’t multiple films receive that score?

1

tommy0guns t1_j25i8rb wrote

Imagine a sequel or remake to that 5 movie, and it’s superior to the original. What do you rate the better film?

1