Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Bad_but_Learning t1_iu68grq wrote

There is no way to prove that reincarnation is real, and making assumptions without using a factual foundation leads to illogical and fallacious thinking/conclusions. Let alone saying that dementia, which has over 400 types, is "premature reincarnation", as each type varies in severity and symptom. Definitely an interesting idea, not bashing that, but I would have left 'assumption' and 'is likely' out of the equation.

13

whenwillitbenow t1_iu6dyq2 wrote

There’s to way to prove anything after death is real. If people want to believe that’s their choice. Logic doesn’t matter, especially in times of need, like grief. People grieve those with dementia because they are being taken from us while we watch. It’s a horror that sometimes they “come back” and then are taken again.

2

Bad_but_Learning t1_iu6fwcv wrote

>If people want to believe that’s their choice. Logic doesn’t matter, especially in times of need, like grief.

Grieving with logic is more difficult, but overall far more healthy. Knowing you only have one chance with loved ones makes the time you have with them that much more cherished. Thinking that your family is waiting for you in some imaginary place, or will come back through reincarnation doesn't let people accept death for what it is, and sometimes treat the living far worse.. because you can "see them after death". If you can't move past the denial stage of grief you won't ever heal or come to terms with reality.

​

>People grieve those with dementia because they are being taken from us while we watch. It’s a horror that sometimes they “come back” and then are taken again.

It's a harsh reality of life, but that doesn't make it easier, I know -- and there isn't really anything anyone could say to make it "better" or easier for the people going through it.

1

tpb772000 OP t1_iu68nel wrote

I tried posting this question 10 times and it kept getting rejected. This wording is the only one that went through lol. Definitely do not like the wording either but at least my point got across.

1