Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

BrownCavsTribe t1_je34hbi wrote

Reply to comment by daveashaw in Led Zeppelin released their album 'Houses Of The Holy' 50 years ago today by YoureASkyscraper

I don't think adding Houses of the Holy to it's namesake album would've tipped the scales away from PG. I don't have a favorite album but I think being a double LP full of absolute bangers I'd give the edge to PG just off sheer volume.

edit - basically, they're all my favorite, but PG is two albums worth of songs so it counts twice.

2

daveashaw t1_je355bo wrote

Respectfully disagree--I think the PG is kind of a bloated mess. It's got some good tracks (like HOTH) and would have made a pretty good single album. As far as I am concerned the HOTH album is the last really good record they put out.

0

SelectionNo3078 t1_je5mngt wrote

agreed. there are only a few double albums that needed to be.

what a solid single album PG would have been.

1