pleasetrimyourpubes

pleasetrimyourpubes t1_jecpgjd wrote

Many "Twitter famous AI people"* have turned on him for the TIMES article / Lex interview, when just a few days ago they were bowing at his feet. Yud is gonna for sure expand his blocklist since he is quite famously thin skinned.

Lex's Tweet about weak men gaining a little power was almost certainly about Yud. Because Yud wanted to leave the youth with the wisdom that "AI is going to kill you before you grow up."

The TIMES article was completely asinine.

*who may or may not know shit about AI.

9

pleasetrimyourpubes t1_jdusbm7 wrote

What scale are you talking here? I can see hive replication and industry being built. But that is not what I think of when I think "goo". I don't see some kind of Gaia style super nano hivemind. Surviving at the nano scale requires virtually all your capability as an organic system. I could see seed AI being propagated through an organic system, but it would be dumb, like an egg floating around, and wouldn't be able to hatch until certain criteria is met.

1

pleasetrimyourpubes t1_jdstlhg wrote

The whole concept originated with a Feynman thought experiment about exponential growth. He never posed it as a real thing just if a small thing replicated a lot it would take over a planet in a seemingly short doubling. There are so many environmental factors that would destroy this self replicating system and many of them are physical limitations of reality. Yet throughout the 90s we had sensationalist stories about how grey goo was just around the corner.

I see similar sensationalism about the nature of intelligence and the current growth of AI systems and am just enjoying being alive to witness it. It's going to get so much better in such a short period of time and all the basilisks in the world aren't going to come fill our nightmares.

5

pleasetrimyourpubes t1_jdsqtfe wrote

Drexler was selling sensational science fiction books as fact and Smalley was just skeptical of it. The idea of industrial nano technology operating outside of the confines of organic chemistry is and always will be science fiction, particularly the self-replicating kind. Drexlers machines and concepts were so far beyond the realm of physical nature that it's a shame Smalley didn't get to live a few years longer to really rebut Drexler. In the end Drexler at least conceded Grey Goo couldn't happen accidentally and would have to be engineered (though I would posit that even if you engineered it it would die as soon as it stripped the atmosphere away or hit lava; again due to the physical constraints nanosystems must exist in).

1