DontWakeTheInsomniac

DontWakeTheInsomniac t1_j1u952n wrote

I don't know how Karelians in Finland view themselves but please bear in mind that if Karelians are indigenous then ethnic Finns & Estonians could be considered indigenous too since they are broadly part of the same ethnic group. They all speak a closely related language, share mythology and folklore.

To answer your question, most Karelians live in Russia which is outside the EU. It also appears that Karelians have a Finnish identity - even in Russia they are taught Finnish in schools. https://minorityrights.org/minorities/karelians/

12

DontWakeTheInsomniac t1_itrrtkd wrote

In fairness, most European writers in the past paid little to no attention to folk beliefs or practices until the 16th century.

References to guising in the 1500s (not 1700s) may only be the first written reference - it does not tell us when the practice actually began.

Lastly, traditions can have more than one origin - they are often accumulated blends from multiple backgrounds. For example we know Christmas is obviously Christian and yet Christmas Trees are not.

Halloween's Celticity is highly romanticised and likely exaggerated but not entirely without basis.

1