DiscoMonkeyz

DiscoMonkeyz t1_iy7h0xw wrote

Yeah the film sucks. This is nothing like it. It's a collection of short stories that build on one another and are somewhat related. It's a simple idea: we develop AI, but how do we control it? Are 3 basic laws enough to keep robots in line and morally good? Can you really establish a set of rules for what is "morally correct"?

2

DiscoMonkeyz t1_iy72hbq wrote

I think at the time it came out, it was probably very hard for people to visualize and fill in the gaps. But you're doing that in 2022, with a lot of sci-fi books, films and tv shows to draw on.

There's a lot that just isn't explained, or explained a lot later or just suggested, but it didn't bother me because I've seen Bladerunner, and the Matrix, etc. etc.

I really enjoyed it, but the plot is a bit meh. It's more about the world building, but then again...it helped reading it now. Not sure I would have enjoyed it as much when it first came out.

1

DiscoMonkeyz t1_ixptjcn wrote

This. I can't believe there are so many people saying you'll love it just because they did.
If you didn't like The Hobbit...I doubt you'll like LOTR just because it's longer and deeper. I personally don't think it has a lot of character development. Not compared to a lot of more modern work. I think it's very unfair and shortsighted to tell someone to go read a book because you loved it, especially when they've clearly said they didn't like the prequel...

IMO, The Hobbit is a fun adventure, but the last 1/4 is dull AF. I can't belive kids want to hear about all the rebuilding of the town and crap....

The LOTR is a good read. I'm not into fantasy, but I enjoyed it. But it's not for everyone. And the Hobbit is a good litmus test.

0