Submitted by contractualist t3_115h6a0 in philosophy
contractualist OP t1_j92rg6n wrote
Reply to comment by Daotar in The Ontology and Epistemology of Morality by contractualist
Its not even morality, just logic. You can't get a "should" conclusion from "is" premises. This is just the naturalistic fallacy.
Daotar t1_j92vx8z wrote
> You can't get a "should" conclusion from "is" premises.
Not according to Mackie, Kitcher, and Joyce. The naturalistic fallacy is an extremely controversial position that has gone out of favor in recent decades due to critiques from people like Rawls, Rorty, and Mackie.
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments