Came to say this. Pizza by George is more than legit. They sell Stromboli, calzone, lattice, and other specialities right out of the case. I have friends who’ve moved all over nh but we grew up in southern Seacoast of nh and we still drive over an hour to pick up pies from George if we are meeting up or providing pies for a party etc.

I've actually had surprisingly good NY style pizza at Amicci's in Keene.