Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

taunugget t1_j9v6pvu wrote

There isn't really any advantage to adding a third symbol when you can just use more binary digits instead. With two binary digits you can have 4 values, and with 32 digits you can have billions. Sticking with binary allows us to build electronics that are fast, cheap, and reliable.

1

nullrecord t1_j9v9jkz wrote

Sure there is - more storage, or more bandwidth.

1

taunugget t1_j9vavfy wrote

You can get more storage/bandwidth by just adding more binary bits. To achieve the same result with a ternary system would require way more cost and effort.

1

nullrecord t1_j9vc0ox wrote

Without that you would never have ADSL or 4G or wifi. Instead of sending 1 bit at the time over the wire, the "bit" can have 64 states, representing 6 bits at a time - a 6-fold increase in bandwidth.

See here for a bit more:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quadrature_amplitude_modulation

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phase-shift_keying#Quadrature_phase-shift_keying_.28QPSK.29

1

taunugget t1_j9vdphu wrote

That's a good point, lots of transceivers do encode/decode signals with multiple levels. I was only thinking about the processing and storage of data. Even a qam-64 symbol needs to be converted to binary to do anything useful with it.

2

nullrecord t1_j9ve7jy wrote

Sure, but as someone wrote in the other comment, even SSD stores multiple voltages per cell to increase storage capacity.

1