Submitted by yellowyellow2 t3_10o3o6j in books

This might be the most disorganized post ever, but I am blown away by the Earthsea books. I made a post a bit ago on here talking about how much I love the first book, and at the time I had never read anything of the series but that. A few comments told me I was in for a treat and that was so true. I knew I was, but wow. I have become so attached to these characters, and I have processed things going on in my personal life through these stories, and I just can't believe it. I know I have more to read in Earthsea ahead of me, but I loved those 4 books so much that they make me want to just start them all over again. I had some quotes that I have nowhere to put that I wanted to share and talk about, and maybe someone else on here wants to yell at me about Earthsea too. :)

Also general warning for spoilers!

I've decided to spare this post the super long quotes that are stuck in my head, but I think about Tenar in Tombs of Atuan a lot, when she weeps for her years wasted serving a useless evil. She weeps because she is free. But before that, I was loving the book, although I will admit I was also waiting for Ged to show up. Once he did I was even happier. And Tenar and Ged together is just so interesting. The dialogue in Earthsea is so interesting, I just want more and more of it when I read it. Once they're out of the tombs, this might be the thing I thought about most after finishing the book.

"She watched him, and never could she have said what was in her heart as she watched him, in the firelight, in the mountain dusk."

I suppose in hindsight it's maybe a bit obvious that that's romantic, but at the time I wasn't sure. Either way I loved their bond and I love both of their characters.

I really didn't expect The Farthest Shore to be so bleak, but I still really enjoyed it. Only a few pages in I was already so invested in the relationship Ged and Lebannen, which is amazing to me that she can make me love her characters so quickly.

"...and he pushed Arren lightly between the shoulder blades, a familiarity no one had ever taken before, and which the young prince would have resented from anyone else; but he felt the Archmage's touch as a thrill of glory. For Arren had fallen in love."

As soon as I read that I was immediately in. I loved this book. I didn't expect the themes about immortality and consumerism and I enjoyed how she wrote about that, I found some moments a lot spookier than the last two books had been, especially the ending. I was a little sad to hear of Ged being cooped up as an Archmage, and was delighted that apparently that was also how he felt about it. I liked Lebannen's perspective in his youth and not knowing exactly what he should do. And when he starts to distrust Ged a little bit, with the despair. And I keep mentally returning to Ged telling Lebannen that he will not hear the despair, he is not aware of it because he simply refuses to cater to despair. I have a lot of despair in my daily life and this has legitimately helped me process it:

"That selfhood which is our torment, and our treasure, and our humanity, does not endure. It changes; it is gone, a wave on the sea. Would you have the sea grow still and the tides cease, to save one wave, to save yourself? Would you give up the craft of your hands, and the passion of your heart, and the light of sunrise and sunset, to buy safety for yourself, safety forever? ... That is the message that those who know how to hear have heard: by denying life you may deny death and life forever."

After Ged and Lebannen bonding so much it was difficult to read them being in death and being so dry and far away from life. I kept worrying once they returned to life that Ged would die and I feel like if Ursula was a more stereotypical writer he would've just died (and so would I, I have become unreasonably attached to this fictional wizard.) When the Doorkeeper said "He has done with doing. He goes home." I had a lot of ideas that were basically all wrong, and all based on trying to force Ged to retain his power and fame and previous life, somehow.

As a result, Tehanu blew me away.

I loved getting back to Tenar, and I love how she has grown. Questioning her life and her responsibilities and the power of women. Her relationship with Therru is amazing.

"... You have scars, ugly scars, because an ugly, evil thing was done to you. People see the scars. But they see you, too, and you aren't the scars. You aren't ugly. You aren't evil. You are Therru, and beautiful. You are Therru who can work, and walk, and run, and dance, beautifully, in a red dress"

"She had done right to make the dress, and she had spoken the truth to the child. But it was not enough, the right and the truth. There was a gap, a void, a gulf, on beyond the right and the truth. Love, her love for Therru and Therru's for her, made a bridge across that gap, a bridge of spiderweb, but love did not fill or close it. Nothing did that. And the child knew it better than she."

"Wrong that cannot be repaired must be transcended."

I enjoyed her wondering how men would know what a man is, if they have never been around women. It was like Tombs again, I was very happy with Tenar, but I love them together, so I was even happier when Ged arrived. I was very sad about his shame and despair though. I worried he was permanently empty, and I suppose this is mentioned as a possibility from Moss in the book too, that perhaps without his power he is a husk. I have been coping with my life with these books and Ged being that way honestly made me really sad, even after I put the book down for the day. I hated him running away, and I hated Tenar going through the curse and trying to raise Therru with almost no help.

And somehow, in something like the span of four pages, Ursula turned this very beautiful but heart wrenching book into one of the most comforting things I've ever read. Don't get me wrong, I loved the entire book, but I was still sad the old Ged was gone. "Why does Hawk the Goatherd weep for Ged the Archmage?" I guess I needed the time to understand it, just like he did. That the power was never going to give him what he gained there with Tenar. I remember in the previous book Ged saying that maybe he will learn what he was never able to learn once they are finished with the journey and I wondered what he meant. I didn't expect the answer to be so simple and wonderful.

"They lay that night on the hearthstones, and there she taught Ged the mystery that the wisest man could not teach him."

I love their affection, there might not be more for me to say about it beyond that. It is so beautiful to me after getting to know their characters so well. The ending freaked me out with all the creepy wizardry but Therru being named by Kalessin and all deciding to stay in Ogion's house is just perfect. I don't know how she writes so simply but so perfectly, and it strikes me so deeply, emotionally. I feel like I will be returning to these characters for grounding and comfort for a long time. Now, this post is much too long, very sorry!

On a joking note, I find it very funny that Ged has just been casting spells and flying around and in his boat for 50 years before he has sex and once he does he's like you know what, this is pretty cool, actually.

279

Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

Angeldust01 t1_j6cvy4c wrote

Tehanu is probably my favorite Le Guin book. The character writing on Tenar, Therru and Ged was just so strong, and the way she packs some serious truths, wisdom and lots of compassion in seemingly simple sentences was just masterfully done.

About the last two books - I'd suggest reading Tales from Earthsea first, the novel Dragonfly introduces a character that's in The Other Wind, and the other 4 novels have some important/interesting stuff you'll appreciate knowing before going into The Other Wind that'll wrap up all the loose ends and character arcs from previous books satisfyingly.

45

MaudQuickpaw t1_j6d7rn5 wrote

Tehanu is one of my favorite books of all time. I love that Tenar finally becomes the rescuer of Ged, in a way he never knew he would need, and how she brings light and joy to Therru, no magic necessary. In such a magic rich world, having the character who brings the most change be one without magic, but kindness and willpower? Incredible.

Also, Therru's journey is heart wrenching, and beautifully written.

OP, I'm glad you're enjoying this series! It's wonderful.

21

yellowyellow2 OP t1_j6ex48p wrote

I love both of these comments! Couldn’t agree more. I will probably start Tales today.

1

ttthrowaway987 t1_j6efbxy wrote

DNFed the series at Tehanu. It wasn't great up to that point but took a dive right off a cliff.

−6

Abba_Fiskbullar t1_j6djae6 wrote

I didn't like Tehanu when it came out, but I realized it was because at 16 I just didn't have enough context. I read the Earthsea books to my daughter recently, and now finally in my late '40s it all had context and resonance I couldn't see at 16.

24

BookishBitching t1_j6cylsn wrote

Earthsea 😍 tbh she's one of my fave all time authors, hands down.

21

queenhaggard t1_j6dthsf wrote

I avoided Tehanu for so long because I heard it was “too radical,” but when I actually read the book, I realized the people I heard that from were probably men.

21

yellowyellow2 OP t1_j6ewxsl wrote

The criticism of it like that is so funny to me. Her afterword was really good, she mentioned something like people thinking she was taking away Ged’s power as some sort of emasculating punishment, which makes no sense to me seeing as he gave up his power to save and change literally everything, and the only people who have judged him are men obsessed with power.

11

Carioca1970 t1_j6duxpf wrote

I read it when it came out and at first I was bewildered, "Where is all the big magic and high fantasy?" But I was so impressed at how she wrote so beautifully, such a compelling take. Even quiet, nothing is happening scenes, such as cleaning, had a lyrical beauty I could not deny. I dropped my expectation bias then, when this epiphany hit me about half way, and decided it might not be my favorite book by her, but it was definitely the most beautifully written of all of them. Here was a master of her craft coming into her own. Confident, unworried, with breathtaking skill.

11

mojowind t1_j6dpq6b wrote

Thanks for posting. I first read these when I was a 10 year old boy. I remember how much I loved them. So last night I decided to read them again. Really enjoying my change in perspective as an adult, and still enjoying the masterful storytelling.

8

NoisyCats t1_j6e39lz wrote

I remember A Wizard of Earthsea as one of the first novels I ever read as a child. I've recently just reread it and it's the only book I've ever reread. I plan to finish rereading the entire series soon.

As a related point of interest, when I returned to reading again last year, so many decades later, The Left Hand of Darkness was my choice of novel to get me back into it. It's one of the few novels that has made me tear up.

6

bonbonsandsushi t1_j6ed1yn wrote

Ged acknowledging that the shadow is himself is one of the most profound moments in any book. While universal, I wish this epiphany would hit more Americans in particular.

5

dartnj t1_j6ewwun wrote

I first read Wizard of Earthsea when I was 8 years old. (47 years ago) I recently started up the series again and Tehanu blew me away. I’m looking forward to the last 2 books as well. I highly recommend starting from the beginning if you haven’t read the in a while.

3

Funktious t1_j6fb6za wrote

I think you're going to love The Other Wind. Do read Tales of Earthsea first, it's great and introduces some important themes, but this is how I felt about the first 4 books and The Other Wind just blew me away. I really hope it's the same for you!

3

yellowyellow2 OP t1_j6fow6l wrote

I have the omnibus from the library so it’s all in order for me :) i just felt very sad about finishing Tehanu i guess. Of course i will move on and start loving what is ahead of me though, i do this every time. What will be REALLY sad is when there is no more earthsea at all for me to read. I’m sure I’ll love what’s next!

1

Tsquared007 t1_j6ecnyn wrote

100% agreed. I read the first four in the Earthsea cycle for the first time this winter. Amazing to see how Le Guin evolved in her writing and philosophy throughout each book. Tehanu is definitely my favorite by far and I can’t stop thinking about it!! Tenar is such a fantastic, well-built character.

2

PragmaticBadGuy t1_j6f4f8k wrote

I read the first one as a kid and I remember a good amount as I liked it. I only found other there was sequels a few years ago but never read them.

It had great world building.

2

happy_bluebird t1_j6gazah wrote

I think I thought these were YA? Would I enjoy these if I don't like most YA novels?

2

yellowyellow2 OP t1_j6gbo0s wrote

I think they are technically YA, ursula definitely started writing them for young adults, but she is such a top notch writer that I would definitely suggest them to adults. Especially Tehanu, i have seen a ton of people say they didn’t grasp it when they were younger.

6

tommy_the_bat t1_j6hesbw wrote

Damn I need to read these books again.

2