Submitted by darth_nadoma t3_zx1ln0 in Futurology
Northstar1989 t1_j1zx47j wrote
Reply to comment by Kidrellik in Russians did such a good job promoting renewable energy and electric vehicles this year. by darth_nadoma
>think it was because they thought they could steam roll Ukraine with half the troops they had and by just YOLO running to Kyiv like they did with the Crimea but Ukraine was ready this time and it ended up being a disaster.
It has more to do with the fact that both the US and European NATO countries have spent a significant portion of the last 8 years arming Ukraine to the teeth in preparation for further Russian attacks.
Also, the only real difference between Ukraine and Kazakhstan here that matters is Ukrainians are white. The US does more than enough naked Imperialism in brown countries that there's no way a similar level of support could have been mustered for Kazakhstan, due to racism...
Kidrellik t1_j1zy77e wrote
>Also, the only real difference between Ukraine and Kazakhstan here that matters is Ukrainians are white.
Well that and it's also much harder to arm a place like Kazakhstan or Azerbaijan. How are you going to do that? You can't go through Central Asia, China isn't going to let you and neither is Iran. Turkey probably will but they're going to charge extremely handsomely.
[deleted] t1_j1zyvrm wrote
[removed]
provocative_bear t1_j20ebbn wrote
The West responded harshly to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine because they were increasingly aligned with the West. If Russia attacks a province that’s already Russian-aligned, it gets a finger wag, if they attack a nation that we’re actually invested in, it’s on like Donkey Kong.
As for whiteness... I don’t think there would just be a simple finger wag if China attacked Taiwan, I think that it would be a full-on proxy war and a diplo-economic disaster for the world.
neglectedselenium t1_j20bgfm wrote
You're wrong, Ukraine was not armed to the teeth. That's BS. They still largely use soviet era tanks, aircraft, etc. A couple of thousands of Javelins and Stingers ≠ armed to the teeth. Another BS is your assertion that the US wouldn't help the brown/non-white people in case of a hypothetical russian invasion. Also wrong.
TheSensibleTurk t1_j2187ix wrote
As a middle eastern native who was on the receiving end of that US imperialism, I can attest that we owe to the US a lot.
The US repaired my grandparents' farm with the Marshall Aid in the 40s.
The US subsidized my dad's medical school tuition and my mom's pharmacy major tuition via USAID funds allocated to urbanization projects.
The US saved my dad's Kurdish relatives in Iraq first during the Gulf War, secondly after the US oversaw the creation of Iraqi Kurdistan.
The US brought me as a then-15 year old Turkish kid to America for a public diplomacy program in 2008.
The US gave me citizenship through the MAVNI program.
I am proud to call myself an American today and I believe that the projection of US power is a good thing for humankind.
Northstar1989 t1_j252xgf wrote
The Kurds are one of the very few groups of brown-skinned people that have, on the balance, largely benefitted from US Imperialism. Until the US abandoned Kurdistan almost entirely to its own fate at the end of the Second Gulf War instead of backing their dream of an independent state, directly leading to ISIS murdering enormous numbers of Kurdistan soon thereafter, of course..
Your experience is largely unique- and would not have occurred if you were a brown person from nearly any other part of the world.
At the same time the US was investing in Kurdish farmers like your grandfather and sending your parents to college, it was doing things like backing a literal genocidal regime in Indonesia, behaving in an initially friendly manner to Apartheid South Africa (until public pressure caused the US to finally start enforcing sanctions), and overthrowing the legitimately-elected Democratic Socialist government of Chile and replacing it with the murderous Pinochet far-right dictatorship that set up concentration camps across the country...
Just because a few lucky family like yours benefitted does NOT mean US influence was a net positive for most people.
TheSensibleTurk t1_j25o8i1 wrote
I'm Turkish, and my grandparents were in Turkey.
Without the US, we would have ended up as a Soviet satellite.
The deposition of Allende was a legitimate act to counter the USSR. Communism is a totalitarian ideology and totalitarian ideologies require extraordinary methods to be combated.
As a soon to be minted foreign service officer and a reservist lieutenant, I will strive until my last breath to see Pax Americana perpetuated.
Northstar1989 t1_j25p9d4 wrote
>The deposition of Allende was a legitimate act to counter the USSR. Communism is a totalitarian ideology and totalitarian ideologies require extraordinary methods to be combated.
Allende was a Democratic Socialist not a "Communist" (by which you mean Authoritarian Socialist, in the style of the USSR) you troll.
His ideology was in no way Totalitarian, and he actively worked to maintain the institutions of Democracy.
Whereas PINOCHET the far-right "Capitalist" dixtator installed by the CIA was absolutely 100% a Totalitarian. He built Concentration Camps.
So by your own words, Pinochet should have been opposed by "extraordinary methods", not been actively supported and installed in the first place by the CIA.
Funny how you right-wing trolls twist morality in on itself so it becomes somehow right to depose a leftist Democracy to replace it with right-wing Totalitarianism.
TheSensibleTurk t1_j25qktq wrote
Sure, in the same way that the so called Democratic People's Republic of Korea is a democratic entity.
Soviet sponsored proletarian revolutions had to be contained.
It happened in Turkey too. Before the 1980 coup, Soviet backed guerillas were wreaking havoc. My father was working at a rural government clinic at the time and he was kidnapped by the revolutionaries and held for ransom. At the height of it, the revolutionaries would set up checkpoints and execute any state employee, Katyn style.
Who put an end to that? Kenan Evren. Look him up.
You cannot treat cancer with antibiotics or painkillers. You treat it with chemotherapy which can hurt like hell. So it is with countering revolutionary Marxism.
Northstar1989 t1_j25s01l wrote
>Sure, in the same way that the so called Democratic People's Republic of Korea is a democratic entity.
Not at all.
There was nothing Totalitarian about Allende's government. Free, multi-party elections continued. The Constitution remained in force (in fact, it was ardent Constitutionalists in the government who fouled the first CIA Coup attempt).
Stop spreading file hatred and right-wing propaganda just because you are unable to face facts.
This has gone on too long. You are clearly a troll, likely a PAID troll. Nothing will stop you from repeating the same nonsense over and over, completely unsupported by facts and heedless of counterarguments.
You are being blocked. Good riddance.
FSOAspirant t1_j25sw9v wrote
You can block a reddit account. You cannot block the continued march of neoliberalism.
grundar t1_j22ftn2 wrote
> Also, the only real difference between Ukraine and Kazakhstan here that matters is Ukrainians are white.
Well, that and the fact that Russia invaded Ukraine.
(Russia sent >100,000 troops to Ukraine in a full-scale invasion, whereas it sent 2,500 troops for 1 week as part of CSTO at the invitation of the Khazakstan government. The situations are not remotely similar, and it's disengenuous at best to pretend otherwise.)
EDIT:
> You're just trolling and not even reading what I wrote.
No, I'm pointing out -- with sources -- how lazy and uninformed your assumption of racism is.
There are fundamental differences between Ukraine and Kazakhstan in terms of their relationships to Russia and the West; to assert that the only relevant difference between them is "Ukraine is white" is verifiably wrong.
Northstar1989 t1_j253im9 wrote
You're just trolling and not even reading what I wrote.
I compared how the US would have responded if Kazakhstan had been invaded instead of Ukraine, I didn't say it had been invaded.
bjplague t1_j2d1myc wrote
more about culture then race really.
slapping the racist label on something then think you drove home your point and move on is lazy work.
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments